Skip to main content
The Legal 500

Executor Disputes

The role of an Executor is an important one and can often be fairly complex, particularly if the deceased had substantial assets or the provisions of the Will are not straightforward.

Executor Disputes in Chesterfield, Sheffield, Dronfield and Mansfield

Talk to Banner Jones. We are ready to help you.

What is an Executor?

An Executor of a Will is the person (or persons) appointed by the deceased to deal with the administration of their estate. Executors have numerous duties, including a duty under Section 25 of the Administration of Estates Act 1925 to collect in the estate and administer it in accordance with the provisions of the Will.

Other aspects of an Executor’s role can include making funeral arrangements, paying the debts of the estate, obtaining a grant of probate, preparing estate accounts and making distributions to Beneficiaries.

Where a person dies without making a Will, the person dealing with their estate is called an Administrator, but they essentially have the same duties as Executors, albeit as there is no Will, the rules of intestacy must be followed.

The role of an Executor is an important one and can often be fairly complex, particularly if the deceased had substantial assets or the provisions of the Will are not straightforward.

Contact us

Disputes with Executors

Disputes with Executors can arise for many different reasons, but typically involve Beneficiaries who consider that the Executor is not performing their duties satisfactorily or in a timely manner.

Common complaints include unreasonable delays in the administration process, failure to identify all assets of the deceased or a lack of transparency in the administration process.

A failure to administer the estate properly and in a reasonable time by the Executor can lead to financial loss by the Beneficiaries, such as a loss of interest on pecuniary legacies and fines for late payment of inheritance tax. Claims can be made against the Executor for these losses and Banner Jones have considerable experience in dealing with Executor disputes.  Many Executor disputes can be resolved collaboratively by negotiation and increased communication between Beneficiaries.

Contact us

Removal of an Executor

Where it does not prove possible to resolve Executor disputes informally, Section 50 of the Administration of Justice Act 1985 provides a mechanism to seek the removal or substitution of an Executor/Administrator. Such an application has to be supported by compelling evidence as the court will not remove an Executor/Administrator lightly.

For an application to remove an executor to be successful, an applicant must demonstrate that the Executor’s conduct (or lack of) is sufficient to show that they are either incapable of unsuitable to carry out their duties. 

A successful application to remove/substitute an Executor or Administrator will enable an alternate Executor to take over the administration and progress the matter through to conclusion.

Get in touch with our team today

Trust Registration Service

Free guide

Trust Registration Service

If you are a Trustee, you need to be aware that new rules came into force in October 2020 extending the requirement to register Trusts with the Trust Registration Service (TRS).

Download now

From the minute you walk into reception you are put at ease, and this continues right through the chain. Would recommend them any time.

Mr G, Chesterfield

Meet the Team

Rob Stubbs

  • Director
  • Solicitor
  • Head of Dispute Resolution
Executor Disputes Team Members

Talk to Banner Jones. We are ready to help you.

Want to know more?

Frequently Asked Executor Disputes Questions

Is it possible to challenge a Will?

Yes.  There are a number of circumstances in which it is possible to challenge the validity of a Will.   These include a lack of capacity or knowledge or approval of the testator, undue influence or fraud.  Should you have any concerns regarding the validity of a Will, you should obtain legal advice from experienced will dispute solicitors such as Banner Jones as a matter of urgency.

What if I have been left out of a Will or am unhappy with the amount that has been left to me?

Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family & Dependants) Act 1975, it is possible for certain individuals to pursue a claim if they can demonstrate that the financial provision made for them is inadequate or unreasonable. If you are considering disputing a Will, our team of trust dispute solicitors can advise you on your options.

What is a Caveat and how does it work?

A caveat is a legal document issued by the Probate Registry that prevents a grant of probate being issued.  The caveat will remain in place for a period of 6 months (unless voluntarily removed by the person entering it or by an order of the Court.  A caveat can be renewed after 6 months. Caveats should not be obtained lightly or without justifiable reason as the Court can impose financial sanctions where it considers that a caveat has been improperly obtained. It is therefore advisable to obtain specialist legal advice from estate dispute solicitors before seeking to lodge a caveat.

Would I have to attend a court hearing if I pursue a claim?

Not necessarily.  Our objective in any dispute is to seek to a successful resolution as quickly and cost-effectively as possible.  This can include seeking to negotiate informally, attending a mediation and other methods of alternative dispute resolution.  The vast majority of will and trust disputes do not reach a final court hearing.

Under what circumstances can I challenge the validity of a Will?

It is possible to challenge a Will If you believe it was not made correctly or fairly. Common grounds include lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, or fraud. If you are disputing a Will UK, it is important to seek early advice from will dispute lawyers to protect both your position and the estate.

What does “lack of testamentary capacity” mean?

Lack of testamentary capacity refers to situations where the person creating the will may not have understood the nature of the document, their assets, or the implications of their decisions due to illness or diminished mental capacity.

What is “undue influence”, and how does it affect a Will?

Undue influence happens when a person is either pressured or coerced into changing or making a Will. If prove, the Will may be declared invalid.

How long do I have to contest a Will or make a claim against an estate?

Most claims under the 1975 Act must be made within 6 months from the date probate was granted. Contact our Will dispute solicitors as soon as possible to ensure you avoid missing key deadlines.

What happens if an Executor is not performing their duties correctly?

Where an Executor is not performing their duties, are mismanaging the estate or are failing to act in the best interests of the estate or beneficiaries our estate dispute solicitors can help apply to the court to remove them or replace them.

Executor Disputes Resources

Mis-Sold Property Trust Case Study: How Our Legal Team Reclaimed a Family Home

Mis-Sold Property Trust Case Study: How Our Legal Team Reclaimed a Family Home

A couple lost control of their home due to a mis-sold property trust. Learn how our dispute resolution solicitors in Chesterfield and Sheffield successfully reversed the arrangement through the High Court.

DIY Will Disaster: How Poor Drafting Led to Probate Problems

DIY Will Disaster: How Poor Drafting Led to Probate Problems

A poorly drafted DIY Will led to probate delays and legal uncertainty. Learn how our Probate solicitors in Sheffield helped the family navigate the fallout and protect their rights.

Why Using a Professional Will Solicitor in Sheffield Matters More Than Ever

Why Using a Professional Will Solicitor in Sheffield Matters More Than Ever

If you haven’t made a will yet—or if you’ve used a DIY service—it’s time to think again. With more people than ever challenging wills in court, having your will written by a professional will solicitor in Sheffield is no longer just a good idea—it’s essential.

Court fee increase

Court fee increase

The Ministry of Justice (MOJ) has announced that from 8th April 2025, 171 court and tribunal fees will increase.

Son successfully contests late mother's £700,000 will after evidence revealed his sister “helped” her sign it

Son successfully contests late mother's £700,000 will after evidence revealed his sister “helped” her sign it

In a recent legal case, a son successfully contested his late mother's £700,000 will after evidence revealed that his sister had physically manipulated their ailing mother's hand to sign the document.

How to Make a Will

How to Make a Will

Making a Will is commonly associated as something you do in later life however, in reality anyone over the age of 18 can have a Will and we would strongly recommend it to anyone with children.

Challenging a Will

Challenging a Will

We know that challenging a will can be a really stressful and emotional time so in this video our Head of Dispute Resolution, Rob Stubbs, covers the options available to you. This includes how you can challenge the validity of a will and your options under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependents) Act.

What is Contentious Probate, and how does it affect me?

What is Contentious Probate, and how does it affect me?

Discover what contentious probate means and how disputes over Wills and estates are resolved. Speak to our expert contentious probate solicitors at Banner Jones for clear advice and practical solutions. 

Types Of Wills Explained

Types Of Wills Explained

Kathryn Wheeldon discuses the different types of Wills that are available, and how to decide which one to choose.

Trust Registration Service

Trust Registration Service

If you are a Trustee, you need to be aware that new rules came into force in October 2020 extending the requirement to register Trusts with the Trust Registration Service (TRS).

Judge rules to uphold deathbed Will

Judge rules to uphold deathbed Will

The England & Wales High Court has upheld a Will executed on his deathbed by a man who left everything to his long-term partner. Lee Foster, Director and Will Dispute specialist said, “The law provides individuals with wide discretion on how their estate should be distributed on their death; although there are specific circumstances under which this discretion can be challenged”.

Will the new video witnessing laws cause a rise in future Will disputes?

Will the new video witnessing laws cause a rise in future Will disputes?

Lee Foster, Dispute Resolution Solicitor and ACTAPS member considers this.

Wills - The importance of getting it right

Wills - The importance of getting it right

The Coronavirus has affected everyone in many different ways, but one thing is for sure, it has provided a reminder to many of us about the importance of having our personal affairs in order. For most people this process starts by writing a Will.

Daughter loses High Court battle over mother’s estate after judge rules Will was forged

Daughter loses High Court battle over mother’s estate after judge rules Will was forged

A Nottinghamshire man who took his sister to court over claims she faked her mother’s Will in a bid to unlawfully claim almost half of her estate has today spoken of his relief after the High Court ruled that the document was a forgery.

Online Privacy in the Office

Online Privacy in the Office

Companies are within their rights to monitor the private online activities of their employees when they are in the office.

Birth Injury- The patient’s right to information

Birth Injury- The patient’s right to information

A woman recently won damages on behalf of her son for injuries sustained at his birth as a result of the alleged negligence of a consultant obstetrician and gynaecologist.

Divorce Survival Tips

Divorce Survival Tips

We’ve enlisted the help of some local relationship counsellors in Sheffield to provide you with some survival advice to help get you through a divorce.

Wills writing

Jenna was fantastic, I will definitley recommend to family and friends. I will not hesitate to use your services again.

Mr & Mrs B, Sheffield

We wish to thank Banner Jones for incredible assistance in guiding us and explaining the process of our Wills and LPA'S.

Mr & Mrs S, Chesterfield

From the minute you walk into reception you are put at ease, and this continues right through the chain. Would recommend them any time.

Mr G, Chesterfield

I can’t thank Banner Jones enough for the kindness and patience, and would highly recommend this firm.

Mrs S, Chesterfield

Will Writing

Excellent company. Highly satisfied.

Mrs H, Ashgate

Probate Administration

Exceptional service; professional but friendly. Felt at ease and relaxed when given explanation of the matter being dealt with at a very sad time.

Mrs L, New Tupton

We had Wills drawn by a different solicitor’s firm who left us confused and anxious. By contrast, the solicitor was patient, helpful, clear and gave us good advice. Thank you for an excellent service. We recommend Banner Jones highly for Will writing.

Mr & Mrs G, Old Tupton

Will Writing

Excellent customer service. Prompt and efficient. I found Jenna to be kind and considerate during our meetings.

Mr & Mrs H, Hasland

The young lady was so friendly and helpful, and made me feel comfortable – which is a rare thing these days

Mrs T, Sutton In Ashfield

Will Writing

Very helpful and pleasant. She was very professional, and answered all my queries. I would have no hesitation for asking for her assistance if ever I need a solicitor in the future.

Mrs R, New Whittington

We take data privacy very seriously, and we want you to understand and feel confident about how we collect, store and handle your personal data. If you’d like to find out more you can read our Privacy Policy.